Review: How To Succeed In Politics

“Being a backbench MP in a majority government caucus is, without a doubt, the worst job in Canadian politics,” writes MP Brent Rathgeber. Irresponsible Government documents the misery.

MPs vote on bills they haven’t read, and deliver speeches they didn’t write. They are paid not to think, Rathgeber concludes; even behind closed doors the Conservative caucus is forbidden from casting free votes on any bill or motion: “The people’s elected representatives have failed miserably.”

Rathgeber’s writing is clear and compelling; he damns the 41st Parliament with a methodical narrative you’d expect of a former trial attorney. Committee hearings are a “sham”; speeches are “canned”; MPs are “automatons”; votes on crucial legislation are mere rituals: “Too many times I have heard a disengaged member inquire of his or her neighbour, ‘Which vote are we on? We’re voting ‘yeah’, right?’”

The author is no greenhorn; Rathgeber served in the Alberta legislature, a one-party state with its own brand of brawling politics, and two terms in the Commons. Yet confronted with the mindless partisanship of Parliament, Rathgeber decided – enough. His account of political life is unsettling.

Irresponsible Government begs the question, why do MPs put up with it? The answer is pathetic and merely human: compliant MPs are no worse than reporters who grovel for cabinet interviews, or Department of Justice lawyers who write unconstitutional bills, or RCMP officers who act as bouncers at Conservative Party rallies: the path of expediency is easy and never troublesome, even if it runs along the ditches.

Rathgeber credits a crude system of favours and punishments. Pliable MPs win plum committee assignments, perhaps a junket to Singapore, and a cushy office to impress out-of-town visitors. Dissenters are berated by apparatchiks, stripped of perks and reminded daily of who’s boss. “I was not a team player,” he notes.

Irresponsible Government settles no scores; Rathgeber does not name the worst culprits in Hill shenanigans, though he could. He merely presents the case to the jury of electors: this is what you voted for.

Rathgeber resigned from caucus in 2013 when Conservative friends gutted his private bill on salary disclosure. This was no radical measure; Ontario pioneered its so-called Sunshine List in 1996 with a Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act that required publication of names and benefits of all public officials paid more than $100,000 a year. To date Alberta, Manitoba, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick have enacted similar measures.

In committee a small drama played out as Conservative staff directed MPs to cut up Rathgeber’s bill; one member, Brad Butt of Mississauga-Streetsville, Ont., did the chore by introducing an amendment he hadn’t written: “I want to be able to read it just so people back home think I really work here,” he quipped. Butt questioned the bill; he had to say something. it was embarrassing:

  • •BUTT: “I’m trying to wrap my head around what the real public benefit value is of average citizens filing these Access To Information requests all the time, to find out what someone’s salary is at a medium level within the public service. What is the ultimate overall benefit of that?…Did you do any financial analysis of what the costs might be to administer a program like this?”
  • •RATHGEBER: “No, because I don’t know how many there will be…”
  • •BUTT: “Do we know how many individuals there are at the $160,000-a year or higher?…”
  • •RATHGEBER: “We can’t know, Mr. Butt, because currently the government will only disclose ranges of salaries.”

Disclosure was quashed; Rathgeber quit. And the MP from Streetsville? Butt last February 24 admitted to the Commons he’d lied about witnessing a felony in the last election, but was defended by Conservative officials as a good fellow. “Commendable,” the Prime Minister called him.

In one memorable speech MP Tom Lukiwski, parliamentary secretary to the Government House Leader, explained you couldn’t censure Mr. Butt as a liar since Canadians can’t believe a word MPs say anyway: “All members tend to torque their language a bit, perhaps to embellish or to exaggerate”; “Is it distasteful from time to time? It certainly is. Is it personal? Many times it is. Do the members on our side do the same? Yes, we do.”

By Tom Korski

Irresponsible Government: The Decline Of Parliamentary Democracy In Canada, by Brent Rathgeber, MP; Dundurn Press; 168 pages; ISBN 9781-4597-28370; $19.99

Fed Agency Targeted Private Data Weeks Before Court Ban

Federal anti-trust investigators working without warrants filed scores of requests for confidential data from internet service providers in the weeks before the Supreme Court banned the practice, records show. Canadians who had their information surrendered to agents were never told of the incidents. The disclosures came as the Commissioner of Competition pledged “transparency” was his watchword: “This is the guiding vision for the bureau”.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

No Full Compliance On Code

Canada’s telecom firms report compliance with a consumers’ Wireless Code albeit with “delays” by the largest service providers, say regulators. The CRTC issued its first compliance report since enacting the code last December: ‘They had months to get their act together’.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

Tax Vow Draws More Scorn

Provinces caution they’ll expect compensation for lost revenue if cabinet honours an old election promise to lower taxes for wealthier single-income families. The Ontario finance ministry said it would not agree to any tax losses as a consequence of a so-called “income splitting” plan proposed for 2015: “Governments are broke”.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

Canada Post Closes 9 In 10

Canada Post has shuttered more than 90% of offices it targeted for service cuts despite a commitment to ‘consult’ with affected customers, data show. Records indicate of 72 post offices slated for closure or relocation by management since 2010, all but six were shut down as intended: “It is deceptive”.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

“Shocking”: Feds OK 20-Year Sale Of Toxins Without Study

Senators are demanding answers from Health Canada over disclosures that toxic pesticides suspected of environmental damage have been licensed for decades without risk assessments. The Senate agriculture committee learned regulators allowed the sale of 35 chemicals linked to bee deaths from as early as 1995 without requiring that manufacturers submit scientific data on their toxicity: “This is shocking”.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

A Website So Bad Even Gov’t Scientists Couldn’t Fathom It

The National Research Council is being cited for creating a “knowledge management” website so convoluted its own scientists can’t manage it. An internet consultant hired by the government reports the website is “cluttered”; “difficult to search”; “slow” and “cumbersome”: ‘The article is in English but the link leads to a page in German’.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

Tolls No Profit Maker: Report

Another federal report confirms commuter tolls are no certain fix to finance new roads and bridges. The Parliamentary Budget Officer reported tolls needed to recover costs of refitting a federal bridge in Montréal are so high, thousands of commuters would avoid payment by taking alternate routes: ‘It will be catastrophic’.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

Fear Regs Are Now Running On Feds’ Election Timetable

Federal inspectors acknowledge “lots of questions” from processors over long-awaited revisions to regulations on food safety. Industry analysts expressed wariness that cabinet will rush changes in anticipation of a 2015 election: “We haven’t yet seen a shift in thinking”.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

Tax Dep’t To Create Secretive “Informant” System At Work

Canada Revenue Agency is launching a secret surveillance system to spy on employees and managers suspected of “fraudulent activities”. The agency stresses the network will rely on anonymous tips from inside informants, and must operate outside the Access To Information Act. Two-thirds of the tax department’s 40,000 employees have electronic access to tax files, by official estimate: “Fraud and integrity lapses pose a serious threat”.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

Privacy Act Draws A Shrug

The latest federal report on the Privacy Act finds little consultation between government departments on personal information requests. Of 81 applications from Canadians for their own files and documents from government agencies, most were redirected to other departments: “Where are they?”

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)

‘Little Guy’ Win Claimed In Record Copyright Litigation

An Alberta company litigating the largest copyright dispute in the country is citing a win for “the little guy” in Court. Geophysical Service Incorporated won dismissal of a claim that it put up thousands of dollars as a condition of proceeding with a copyright case against a Halifax-based oil and gas company: “It’s very difficult in Canada to protect your interests”.

This content is for Blacklock’s Reporter members only. Please login to view this content. (Register here.)